in the first place
Dec. 8th, 2016 05:08 amIn the dollar store some times ago I got a cheap book titled Great Battles. It is a funny book for me to own being a pacifist. But I find that sort of thing interesting. It starts with the Battle of Marathon and finishes off with the 2003 invasion of Iraq (which they refer to as “Operation Iraqi Freedom”). Each night I read a chapter which covers a different battle, and then I read about the same said battle on Wikipedia. Lately I have been making the rounds through the Napoleonic Wars: Trafalgar, Waterloo etc. Then I read into other subjects like the Napoleon's Continental System, in which he tried to cut the British out of trading in Europe, but this ended up hurting France more than Britain in practice. Also led to invasions into Spain and Russia which resulted into the downfall of the French Empire. I wonder if their are any lessons for us in The Future for that.
Lena has been watching through Star Trek The Next Generation, and we've been watching key episodes together. In The Best of Both Worlds, Picard tours the Enterprise the night before a tough battle with the Borg. He makes his way to Ten Forward and has a conversation with Guinan which is supposed to remind us that, this being the season finale, Anyone Can Die. (Riker is also mulling over a promotion to another ship, and guest Shelby is vying for his job). (Oh noes any cast change could happen)!
Picard: It's something of a tradition, Guinan - Captain touring the ship before a battle.
Guinan: Hmm. Before a hopeless battle, if I remember the tradition correctly.
Picard: Not necessarily. Nelson toured the HMS Victory before Trafalgar.
Guinan: Yes, but Nelson never returned from Trafalgar, did he?
Picard: No, but the battle was won.
Absent a stale spoiler alert, lets just say at the end of part two, all the regulars are back where they started and Shelby is on to other things never to be seen again.
Anyway, reading about Trafalgar, the thing that strikes me about this interaction now is that it seems like Picard is on “our side”. “Our side” being the presumed Anglo-Saxon-American audience which relates more with Nelson than his opponent Pierre-Charles Villeneuve (who by the way, unlike Nelson, lost the battle, but survived). The only problem is that from Picard's perspective Trafalgar wasn't won, but lost. He is after all, nominally French. We even later find out in another story that he had a relative fighting at Trafalgar on the French side.